Located in
Historic Stockyards City.
Old Fashion Pies and Strawberry Shortcake
Cattlemen's Cafe Oklahoma Famous Old Fashion Pies and Strawberry Shortcake
When it comes to ending a good meal, nothing beats the old-fashioned pies at Cattlemen's Cafe in Oklahoma City. Cattlemen’s is known far and wide for their traditional southern flavors, being the oldest restaurant in Oklahoma City it truly is a taste of history.
Whether you’re craving a creamy slice of heaven or a classic fruit-filled favorite, the cream pie, or the strawberry shortcake there is something to hit the spot for any sweet tooth at Cattlemen's Cafe.
Cattlemen’s Cafe Pies Are a Slice of Oklahoma History
Pies have long been a cherished staple in the South for generations. Nothing makes someone feel more at home and welcome than a good old-fashioned Southern pie. From the rich, gooey pecan pie—made from nuts native to the southern United States—to the creamy, tangy buttermilk pie, these desserts have graced family tables for generations. The tradition of pie-making in the South often involves recipes passed down through families, with each generation adding its own touch.
At Cattlemen's Cafe, this Southern pie tradition is alive and well. Cattlemen’s dessert menu features a variety of classic pies that pay homage to Oklahoma’s time-honored recipes. One standout is their Ol’ Fashion Fruit Pie, a crispy, golden treat served piping hot with vanilla ice cream. This dessert captures the essence of Southern comfort food, offering a delightful twist on a beloved classic.
The Sweet Staples of Cattlemen’s Cafe Dessert Menu
If fruit pies aren’t calling your name, Cattlemen’s Cafe has you covered with their rich and decadent cream pies. Perfect for those who crave a silky, smooth dessert, their cream pies deliver every time. The Coconut Cream Pie, one of my personal favorites, is a standout, featuring a creamy coconut filling topped with fluffy whipped cream and a sprinkle of toasted coconut that is as pretty as it tastes.
For chocolate lovers, you can’t go wrong with their Chocolate Silk Pie. This chocolate lovers' dessert is piled high with a velvety chocolate filling nestled in a flaky crust and crowned with a dollop of whipped cream. Whether you’re in the mood for a tropical twist or a chocolatey indulgence, these cream pies are sure to hit the spot.
Cattlemen’s Strawberry Shortcake
If you’re looking for a dessert that’s both classic and celebratory, Cattlemen’s Strawberry Shortcake is the perfect choice. In Oklahoma style, the strawberry shortcake has sweet southern-style biscuits loaded, with fresh strawberries, and a generous topping of whipped cream. It’s the kind of dessert that feels just right for any occasion.
At Cattlemen’s Cafe, the Strawberry Shortcake isn’t just a menu favorite—it’s also their featured dessert option for birthdays. There’s no better way to mark a special day than with a slice of this sweet Southern tradition, complete with a fresh, fruity burst of flavor that will have everyone asking for seconds.
Whether it’s a birthday, a family gathering, or just a casual meal, Cattlemen’s Strawberry Shortcake is the perfect ending to your meal at this iconic Oklahoma eatery.
Visit Cattlemen’s Steakhouse Oklahoma Stockyards
Come visit Cattlemen’s Steakhouse in the heart of Oklahoma Stockyards, a top-rated destination when exploring Oklahoma City!
We’re open bright and early at 6:00 am, serving delicious meals until 10:00 pm Sunday through Thursday, and until 11:00 pm on Friday and Saturday.
You can find us at 1309 S. Agnew, Oklahoma City, OK 73108.
No reservations are needed, but if you’d like to skip the wait, give us a call at 405-236-0416 or drop us an email at info@cattlemensrestaurant.com.
We’re ready to welcome y’all with hearty meals and true Oklahoma hospitality. So swing by Cattlemen’s Steakhouse, where great food and a warm, friendly atmosphere are always waiting.
See ya soon!
Go Back to List